Four million customers, on a list someone made
In September 2021, JPMorgan Chase bought Frank, a startup that helped students apply for financial aid. In the words of the SEC's later complaint, "It acquired Frank in a merger transaction for $175 million" 1. What it thought it was buying, above all, was customers: according to the SEC, Frank's founder represented that the company had data on 4.25 million student users.
The SEC alleges the real number was "less than 300,000" 2. When the bank asked for the customer data to check the claim, the complaint says, the founder retained a data science professor "to use 'synthetic data' to create 4.265 million customer names, addresses, email addresses, birthdays, and other identifying information requested by JPMC" 1, and that list was what a third party was given to validate.
The bank did check. It asked for the data behind the number that mattered most. The trouble was where the evidence came from: from the seller. A check that the seller can satisfy by producing a document is not much of a check when the seller is willing to produce the document.
Diligence that only collects what the seller provides confirms the story it was told. The useful part is trying to break it.
What diligence is for, and what most checklists do instead
Cornell's legal encyclopedia defines due diligence as "the level of reasonable care or attention expected to avoid liability," and notes that it "commonly involves reviewing financial records and other relevant documentation" before an acquisition 3. That is the legal floor. For the strategist on a deal team, the purpose is narrower and more useful: to find out, before signing, whether the claims the price depends on are true.
Most checklists are organized by function: finance, legal, tax, HR, IT, each with dozens of document requests. They are necessary, and they share a weakness. They gather what the target provides, so they are best at finding what the target did not think to hide. Caterpillar's purchase of the Chinese mining-equipment maker Siwei is the other classic case. Siwei "was a publicly traded company with audited financial statements," Caterpillar said afterward; what exposed "deliberate, multi-year, coordinated accounting misconduct" was a physical inventory count carried out as part of the integration, after the deal had closed, and the result was a goodwill charge of "approximately $580 million" 4.
Audited accounts were reviewed. The inventory had not been counted. The checklist below is built around that gap: it starts with the claims, and asks for each what evidence exists that the seller does not control.
The checklist
A. The claim the price rests on. Do these first, before the data room opens.
- Write the one or two claims that, if false, would make the price wrong: customers, growth, margins, a technology, a license, a team.
- Compute how far each can miss before the deal stops paying, using the premium and the synergy case.
- For each claim, name evidence the seller does not control: third-party records, customer calls you arrange, a physical count, public filings, regulators' registers.
- Agree who will test each claim, by when, and what result would stop or reprice the deal.
B. Customers and revenue.
- Revenue by customer for three years, reconciled to the audited accounts and to bank deposits.
- Calls with a sample of customers you choose, not ones the seller selects, including some who left.
- Contract terms for the largest customers: renewal dates, change-of-control clauses, termination rights.
- Concentration: the share of revenue from the top ten customers, and what happens if the largest leaves.
- For user or subscriber claims: independent evidence of activity (payments processed, app store data, server logs reviewed by your own people).
C. The quality of the numbers.
- Earnings adjusted for one-offs, with every adjustment explained and the unadjusted figure beside it.
- Cash conversion: does reported profit turn into cash at the rate peers achieve?
- Working capital trends, especially receivables and inventory growing faster than sales.
- A physical check of the assets that matter: inventory counted, sites visited, equipment seen.
- Related-party transactions and anything booked through entities outside the deal.
D. People and operations.
- The people the value depends on: who they are, their terms, and whether they intend to stay.
- Key suppliers, single points of failure, and contracts that change on a change of control.
- Culture and ways of working, from conversations below the leadership team.
E. Technology, data and legal exposure.
- Ownership of the core technology and data: who wrote it, under which licenses, with what rights.
- Security incidents and the state of controls, reviewed by your own specialists.
- Litigation, regulatory inquiries and compliance history, checked against public records as well as the seller's list.
- Permits and licenses the business cannot operate without, and whether they transfer.
F. The synergy and integration case.
- Each synergy line tested against what the target's data actually shows, not the buyer's model of it.
- Revenue the combination could lose: overlapping customers, customers who chose the target because it was not you.
- The integration plan for the first hundred days, with owners, and what has to be true on day one.
How to use it
- Start with section A, before any documents arriveThe claims list decides where the scarce time goes. Without it, diligence spreads evenly across hundreds of requests and goes deepest where the documents are easiest.
- Rank every check by what it could changeA finding that would move the price or stop the deal goes to the top. Use a sensitivity analysis of the deal model to see which claims carry it.
- Prefer evidence the seller does not controlCustomer calls you arrange, records from banks and payment processors, counts you witness, public filings. Where only seller-provided evidence exists, say so in the findings.
- Write findings as changes to the dealEach finding ends in one of four outcomes: no change, a price change, a protection in the contract, or a reason to walk away.
- Keep a list of what you could not checkThe gaps are findings too. The board should see them before it signs.
A worked example
The company is invented; the shape is the point. One claim, a threshold, independent evidence, and a finding that changed the deal.
Before the board signs
- The claims the price rests on are written down, each with its break-even.
- Each was tested with evidence the seller did not control, or the gap is stated.
- Every material finding ends in a price change, a contract protection, or a decision.
- The list of what could not be checked has been read by the people approving the deal.
- The synergy case has been tested against the target's own data, net of revenue at risk.
- Someone independent of the deal team has tried to argue the board out of it.
For what the price itself should be, see precedent transactions and M&A synergies; for how deals have ended, the acquisition integration record.
Acquisition due diligence checklist
A free, editable Word document built from this guide: the template itself, how to fill it in, and the worked example and review checklist where the guide has them. Stratrix branded, and sent to your work email.
Questions
- What should a due diligence checklist include?
- The claims the price depends on and how to test them independently, then customers and revenue, the quality of the financial numbers, people and operations, technology, data and legal exposure, and the synergy and integration case.
- What is commercial due diligence?
- Commercial due diligence tests the market and customer claims behind a deal: the size and growth of the market, the target's position in it, and whether its customers and revenue are what the seller says.
- How do you verify a target's customer numbers?
- With evidence the seller does not control: payment processor or bank records matched to the customer list, customer calls you choose at random, and independent data on activity. Seller-provided lists alone are not enough.
- What is the most important part of due diligence?
- Testing the claims the price depends on. Every deal has one or two; if they are wrong, nothing else in the checklist will save the deal.
Sources
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (2023). SEC v. Charlie Javice, complaint, Case 1:23-cv-02795 (S.D.N.Y., April 4, 2023). US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- US Securities and Exchange Commission (2023). Press release 2023-74 (April 4, 2023). US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- Legal Information Institute (2026). Due diligence, in Wex. Cornell Law School.
- Caterpillar Inc. (2013). Press release of January 18, 2013 on ERA Mining Machinery (Siwei), exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
Tools to try
- Ansoff move finderFramework: Ansoff Matrix
- Business model canvas builderFramework: Business Model Canvas
- Change readiness checkFramework: Kotter's 8-Step Change Model
- Five Forces scorerFramework: Porter's Five Forces
- SMART goal builderFramework: SMART Goals
- SWOT builderFramework: SWOT Analysis
More from Stratrix
“How much of your growth are you buying, and at what spread?”
See the pack — $499 →Test a decision, free
Set a live decision against the companies that made it before you.
AcquisitionsThe Distance TestDivestituresThe Divestiture TestDiversificationThe Diversification TestMake or buyThe Make-or-Buy TestStratrix Team
Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.
$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →Weekly email
Stratonomics, every Tuesday
One data story every Tuesday: what happened, what it means, and the figures you can quote. Free.