Stratrix
Start here

Shell was ready for 1973 because it had rehearsed it

Shell tells the story of its own planning this way: "In 1973, the global economy was shocked by a major oil crisis. Shell wasn't" 1. In the early 1970s, a small team in its planning group had begun describing several possible futures instead of relying on a single forecast. "By 1973 they had shared these early scenarios with Shell's management," the company's history of its scenario work says, "daring them to think the unthinkable: What if the world faced an oil crisis?" 1

Pierre Wack, the Shell planner most associated with that work, later explained what had gone wrong with the old approach in the opening line of a Harvard Business Review article: "Traditional planning was based on forecasts, which worked reasonably well in the relatively stable 1950s and 1960s" 2. A forecast tells you what will happen. It is of little use on the day something else happens.

That is the whole case for environmental scanning, and the reason most scanning disappoints. A grid of trends filled in once a year is a forecast in a different shape. The work that paid off at Shell was not listing outside forces. It was picking the few that would change a decision, and making sure the people who would have to decide had thought about them before the day came.

A scan that cannot change a decision is a reading list.

Start here

What environmental scanning is for

Chun Wei Choo, drawing on Francis Aguilar's research in the 1960s, defines it as "the acquisition and use of information about events, trends, and relationships in an organization's external environment, the knowledge of which would assist management in planning the organization's future course of action" 3. The last clause is the one to hold onto. The point is not to know about the environment. It is to plan differently because of it.

The macro environment is the part of the outside world no single company controls: the economy, technology, politics and regulation, society and demographics, the natural environment. Most strategists meet it through a checklist, PESTLE or STEEP. A checklist is one way to scan. There are at least three others, and each answers a different question.

In practice

Four ways to scan, and the question each answers

Way to scanThe question it answersWhen it fitsWhere it misleads
The checklist (PESTLE, STEEP)Have we missed a whole category of outside force?Annual planning; a new market; a fresh teamLists what everyone knows; says nothing about timing
Signals (horizon scanning)Is something we care about starting to move?Between plans; fast-moving marketsDrowns in noise without a short watch list
ScenariosWhat would we do if the future went one of a few very different ways?Big, long-lived commitments under real uncertaintyBecomes storytelling if no decision is tested against it
Other companies' own wordsWhat are customers, suppliers and rivals already seeing and doing?Any time; the cheapest early warning there isCompanies disclose late and frame things kindly

The checklist is for coverage. It forces a team to ask about each category at least once, which is how blind spots get found. The PESTEL analysis worksheet adds the step most grids skip: sorting each factor into what is settled and what is uncertain, and naming its effect on you. STEEP is the same idea with five categories; the choice between them matters far less than what you do with the result.

Signals are for timing. Instead of describing the world once a year, you pick a handful of indicators that would move first if a force you care about were arriving, and watch them. A signal is useful only if it is specific: not "interest in AI" but "three of our ten largest customers mention cutting the teams our product serves".

Scenarios are for uncertainty that will not resolve before you have to commit. Pick the two forces that are both most important and most uncertain, describe how the world looks at each combination, and test your strategy against every one. Shell's 1973 work is the famous case; scenario planning shows how practitioners run it today.

Other companies' own words are the most underused source. Customers, suppliers and competitors describe what they see in annual reports, earnings calls and filings, and they act on it: layoffs, acquisitions, the rivals they name. Stratrix tracks some of these signals across listed companies: layoffs, acquisitions and the competitors companies name in their own filings.

In practice

Turn any scan into a watch list

Whichever way you scan, the output that matters is short. A watch list has five or fewer lines, and every line has five parts.

PartWhat to writeExample (fictional)
The forceThe outside change, in one lineCustomers automating the work our software supports
The decision it would changeWhich of our choices would we make differently?Whether to keep pricing per user
The sign to watch forA specific, observable indicatorTwo of our top ten customers cut the teams that use our product
Who watches, and how oftenA named person and a rhythmHead of customer success, monthly
What we do if it movesThe response agreed in advanceBring the pricing review forward to the next quarter

The fourth column is where most scans die. A force with nobody assigned to watch it is a paragraph in a strategy document, and it will be noticed at the same moment it is noticed by everyone else.

In practice

How to run a scan in a day

  1. Start from the decisions, not the categoriesList the three or four biggest choices in your strategy. The scan exists to test them.
  2. Run the checklist fastOne pass through PESTLE or STEEP for coverage, with a time limit. Note any force that touches one of your decisions.
  3. Read what others are sayingPull the latest annual reports and call transcripts of your three biggest customers, suppliers and rivals. Note what they say is changing and what they are doing about it.
  4. Sort settled from uncertainSettled forces go into the plan as assumptions. Uncertain ones that matter go onto the watch list, or into scenarios if two of them dominate.
  5. Write the watch list and assign itFive lines at most, each with a sign, a watcher, a rhythm and a response.
Advanced

Mistakes that make scanning useless

  • Scanning once a year. The forces that hurt rarely wait for the planning calendar. A watch list reviewed monthly does more than a grid refreshed annually.
  • Listing trends without effects. "Aging population" is a fact. "Our customer base shrinks 2 percent a year unless we reach younger buyers" is a finding. Write the second kind.
  • Mistaking volume for vigilance. Two hundred tracked signals means nobody is watching any of them. Five is enough.
  • Only scanning the familiar. Ask once a year what force from outside your industry could matter most. The answer is often in another industry's filings first.
  • No decision attached. If nobody can say which choice a force would change, it does not belong on the list.

Questions

What is environmental scanning?
Environmental scanning is gathering and using information about events, trends and relationships outside an organization to help plan its future course. Its value lies in changing decisions, not in describing the environment.
What is the macro environment?
The macro environment is the part of the outside world no single company controls: economic, technological, political and legal, social and demographic, and environmental forces. It is usually examined with a PESTLE or STEEP checklist.
What is the difference between PESTLE and STEEP?
Both are checklists of macro-environmental categories. PESTLE covers political, economic, social, technological, legal and environmental forces; STEEP covers social, technological, economic, environmental and political. The choice matters less than sorting what you find into settled and uncertain, and naming its effect on you.
How often should you do environmental scanning?
A full checklist pass once a year, with the planning cycle, and a short watch list of signals reviewed monthly by named people.
What is horizon scanning?
Horizon scanning is watching for early signals that a force you care about is starting to move, rather than describing the environment once a year. It works best with a short list of specific signals, each with a person watching it.

Sources

  1. Shell International (2013). 40 Years of Shell Scenarios. Shell International BV.
  2. Wack, P. (1985). Scenarios: Uncharted Waters Ahead. Harvard Business Review (September–October 1985).
  3. Choo, C. W. (2001). Environmental scanning as information seeking and organizational learning. Information Research 7(1), paper 112.

Tools to try

More from Stratrix

Strategy Packs
The Enterprise AI Deployment

“What is stopping a working pilot from reaching production?”

One decision per pack: the framework, a working model, the sourced cases and the board material.

See the pack — $499 →

Stratrix Team

Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.

$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →

Weekly email

Stratonomics, every Tuesday

One data story every Tuesday: what happened, what it means, and the figures you can quote. Free.

We'll email you a link to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.