A government that will not spend without one
The UK government has been refining one business case method for more than a decade, and it is not optional. Its current guidance says it is "mandatory for officials in the Welsh Government and UK Government to follow this guidance when developing proposals that involve significant public spending," and everyone who develops, reviews or approves those proposals must be trained and accredited in it 1.
The most useful line in that guidance is not about format at all. A business case, it says, "is not merely a writing exercise or something to complete in order to obtain approval"; it is "a way of thinking through a proposal in a structured and disciplined way" 1. And a good one "shows where proposals do not represent value for money and thus should be halted or reset" 1.
Read that last sentence again. A business case is supposed to be able to say no. Most templates are built so it cannot.
If your business case could not have reached the opposite conclusion, it is not a case. It is a brochure.
Why most templates produce approval documents
The standard outline runs: executive summary, background, options, costs and benefits, risks, recommendation. It looks neutral. In practice it does two things. It lets the author pick the conclusion first and fill the sections toward it, and it puts the assumption the whole case depends on in the risks section, near the end, as one bullet among twenty.
This template changes the order. Page one carries the decision and the three numbers that matter: what it costs, what it adds in today's money, and what has to be true. It also carries the line most cases leave out, the result that would make you stop. The five sections behind it borrow the UK government's Five Case Model, which looks at a proposal from five angles: "the strategic case, the economic case, the commercial case, the financial case and the management case" 1, renamed here for a company rather than a ministry.
The template: page one, then five sections
Page one is the case. Everything after it is the proof a skeptic can check.
| Field | What to write |
|---|---|
| The recommendation | What we should do, and by when, in one sentence. |
| What it costs | All cash out, by year, including people's time and one-time costs. |
| What it adds | Net present value at an agreed discount rate, with the rate and who agreed it. |
| What has to be true | The assumption the result turns on most, and its break-even value. |
| How we will know early | The test of that assumption, its owner and its date. |
| What would make us stop | The result of that test, or any other signal, at which we halt or reset. |
| What we are not doing | The best alternative this displaces, including doing nothing. |
| Section | What it answers |
|---|---|
| 1. Why this, why now | The problem or opportunity, what happens if we do nothing, and how this fits the strategy. (The Five Case Model's strategic case.) |
| 2. The options and their value | Three to five real options, including doing nothing, each with its cost and value in today's money, and why the recommended one wins. (The economic case.) |
| 3. How we will buy or build it | Suppliers, contracts, partners or the build plan, and what each commits us to. (The commercial case.) |
| 4. Can we afford it | Cash by year against the budget, where the money comes from, and what it does to this year's numbers. (The financial case.) |
| 5. Who delivers it, and how we will know | The owner, the plan, the early test, the measures after launch and the stop rule. (The management case.) |
How to fill it in
- Write the options before the recommendationList at least three real options, including doing nothing, and value each one before you choose. A case written to one conclusion compares it with straw men.
- Count the cost in cash, by yearThe day money leaves, not the day it is depreciated. Include the people who will stop doing something else.
- Value it at a rate someone has agreedUse net present value, with the discount rate stated. Show the internal rate of return beside it if your committee expects one, but decide on value; see NPV vs. IRR.
- Find the hingeMove each assumption to a plausible low and high and rank the swings. The widest is the hinge; its break-even value goes on page one. Sensitivity analysis shows how, with a workbook.
- Write the stop rule nowName the result that would make you halt or reset, before anyone has committed to the project. A threshold set in advance is far easier to honor than one negotiated later.
- Write page one last, and make it stand aloneA reader who sees only page one should know what you recommend, what it costs, what it adds, what it rests on and when you will know.
A filled-in page one
Every figure on that page comes from one model, the fictional launch used on the sensitivity analysis page, where its workbook computes them. The pre-sale threshold is a judgment the team would have to make and defend; the template's job is to make it write the judgment down.
Scale it to the decision
Not every decision needs five sections. A $50,000 tool purchase needs page one and a paragraph on options. A product launch needs page one and sections 1, 2 and 5. An acquisition or a new plant needs all of it, with the commercial and financial sections in full, and a synergy case of its own; see M&A synergies.
The UK guidance makes the same point in its own way: it builds a case in stages, from an outline to a full case, with a review at each gate that asks whether the proposal is "still required, affordable and achievable" 1. The test for a company is simpler. Write as much as it takes for a skeptic to find the hinge, and no more.
Before you send it
- Page one stands alone: recommendation, cost, value, hinge, test, stop rule, alternative.
- Doing nothing is one of the options, valued honestly.
- Every figure on page one traces to a cell in the model, and every input in the model to a source or a named judgment.
- The discount rate is stated, with who agreed it.
- The hinge assumption has a break-even value and an owner.
- The stop rule was written before approval, not after.
- A reader who disagrees with the recommendation can find, in one minute, the number they would have to change.
Business case template
A free, editable Word document built from this guide: the template itself, how to fill it in, and the worked example and review checklist where the guide has them. Stratrix branded, and sent to your work email.
Questions
- What should a business case template include?
- A one-page summary with the recommendation, total cost by year, the value it adds in today's money, the assumption it depends on most with its break-even, the early test, the condition for stopping and the alternative it displaces. Behind it: why now, the options and their value, how it will be bought or built, whether it is affordable, and who will deliver it.
- What is the Five Case Model?
- The UK government's standard framework for business cases. It looks at a proposal through five cases: strategic, economic, commercial, financial and management. Officials must follow it for proposals involving significant public spending.
- How long should a business case be?
- As long as the decision needs. A small purchase may need one page; an acquisition needs every section in full. Whatever its length, page one should stand alone.
- What is the difference between a business case and a project charter?
- A business case argues whether to do something and which option to choose. A project charter, written once the decision is made, sets out the scope, owner, milestones and authority for doing it.
Sources
- HM Treasury and Welsh Government (2026). Guidance on developing business cases for projects and programmes. GOV.UK.
For information and strategic analysis only, not investment advice. Stratrix does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security.
Tools to try
- Business model canvas builderFramework: Business Model Canvas
- Change readiness checkFramework: Kotter's 8-Step Change Model
- Five Forces scorerFramework: Porter's Five Forces
- Ansoff move finderFramework: Ansoff Matrix
- SMART goal builderFramework: SMART Goals
- SWOT builderFramework: SWOT Analysis
More from Stratrix
“What did the decision you did not take actually cost?”
One decision per pack: the framework, a working model, the sourced cases and the board material.
See the pack — $499 →Test a decision, free
Set a live decision against the companies that made it before you.
AcquisitionsThe Distance TestDivestituresThe Divestiture TestDiversificationThe Diversification TestMake or buyThe Make-or-Buy TestStratrix Team
Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.
$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →Weekly email
Stratonomics, every Tuesday
One data story every Tuesday: what happened, what it means, and the figures you can quote. Free.