One Microsoft, in one sentence
On July 11, 2013, Steve Ballmer sent Microsoft's employees a memo about how the company would be organized. Its central line was a statement of strategy, not structure: "We are rallying behind a single strategy as one company — not a collection of divisional strategies" 1. The structure followed from it. "This means we will organize the company by function," the memo went on, listing engineering, marketing, business development and evangelism, advanced strategy and research, finance, HR, legal, and a chief operating officer's group 1. Engineering itself would be split into "four engineering areas: OS, Apps, Cloud, and Devices" 1.
Whatever you think of how it turned out, the memo is a clean example of what an operating model is. It started from a strategic choice, one company rather than a federation of divisions, and drew the organization to fit. It is easy to run it the other way: draw a new chart first, then write the strategy it is meant to serve afterward, to explain it.
The chart is also only the most visible part. Who decides, how work moves between units, what people are measured and paid on: those change less often than boxes and lines, and they decide more. An operating model that redraws the boxes and leaves them alone tends to look new and behave old.
The org chart is the easiest part of an operating model to change, and the least likely, on its own, to change anything.
What an operating model is made of
Jay Galbraith's Star Model is the most useful way to see the pieces. "In the Star Model," he wrote, "design policies fall into five categories. The first is strategy, which determines direction. The second is structure, which determines the location of decision-making power. The third is processes, which have to do with the flow of information" 2. The fourth is rewards, which "influence the motivation of people to perform and address organizational goals", and the fifth is people: the policies that shape employees' mind-sets and skills 2. His central claim is the one to remember: "For an organization to be effective, all the policies must be aligned and interacting harmoniously with one another" 2.
Note where Galbraith puts decision-making power: in structure. That is the practical test of any operating model. Ask who makes the five or six decisions the strategy depends on most, and whether the design makes them easy or hard to make well. Stratrix's framework page on Galbraith's Star Model covers the model itself; this template applies it.
The template: the model on two pages
| Section | What to write |
|---|---|
| 1. The strategy it serves | The two or three strategic choices the operating model must make easy to carry out, quoted from the strategy. |
| 2. The decisions that matter most | The five or six recurring decisions those choices depend on, such as pricing, which customers to serve, product priorities or where to invest. |
| 3. Structure | How units are grouped (by product, customer, region or function), and why that grouping makes the decisions in section 2 easier. |
| 4. Decision rights | For each decision in section 2: who decides, who must be consulted, who can veto. Use the table below. |
| 5. Processes and the flow of work | The few cross-unit flows that carry the strategy (from order to delivery, from idea to launch) and who owns each end to end. |
| 6. Rewards and measures | What leaders and teams are measured and paid on, and whether it pulls toward the strategy or away from it. |
| 7. People and capabilities | The roles and skills the design needs, the gaps, and how they will be filled. |
| 8. What changes, and what stays | The moves from today's model to the new one, in order, with the date each takes effect and the risks of the transition. |
| Column | What to write |
|---|---|
| Decision | One recurring decision from section 2, in plain words. |
| Who decides today | As it actually happens, not as the chart says. |
| Who should decide | Under the new model. |
| Who is consulted | People whose input is required before the decision. |
| Who can stop it | Any veto, written down so it is not discovered later. |
| Why this placement | One sentence tying it to the strategy. |
How to fill it in
- Start with the decisions, not the boxesWrite sections 1 and 2 before anyone draws a chart. If the team cannot agree on the five decisions that matter most, the chart will not settle it.
- Map decision rights as they are todayInterview the people who make each decision now. The gap between the chart and reality is usually the most useful finding of the whole exercise.
- Choose the grouping that serves the decisionsGroup by customer if the key decisions are about customers; by product if they are about products; by function if scale and consistency matter most, as in Microsoft's 2013 design. Each grouping makes some decisions easier and others harder; say which.
- Check the rewards against the strategyIf business unit heads are paid on their own profit and the strategy needs them to share customers, the model will not work, whatever the chart says.
- Sequence the changeDecision rights and measures can change in weeks; structure and people take longer. Write the order and the dates.
- Test it against a real weekWalk three real decisions from last month through the new model. If any gets slower or stuck, fix the design before announcing it.
A filled-in example
The company is invented. Notice what the example spends its words on: the decisions and who makes them. The new unit is one line.
Target operating model: a destination, not a document
A target operating model is the operating model you intend to have at a future date, written so the gap from today can be planned. It is useful when the change is large and will take years, as in a merger or a move into a new kind of customer. The risk is that the target becomes a finished document while the company keeps running on the old model. Keep the target short, put dates on each step, and review progress in the same meeting as the strategy; see strategy execution.
Before you announce it
- Every section traces back to a strategic choice in section 1.
- Each of the most important decisions has one owner, written down.
- The decision rights reflect who will actually decide, not who is senior.
- Rewards pull in the same direction as the strategy.
- Three real decisions from last month have been walked through the new model.
- The order of changes is written, with dates, and the structure is not the only thing changing.
- Someone has said what the new model will make harder, and the leadership team has accepted it.
For the decision rights themselves, RACI vs. RAPID vs. DACI compares the common ways to write them down, and the decision rights chart builder produces a chart for one decision at a time.
Operating model template
A free, editable Word document built from this guide: the template itself, how to fill it in, and the worked example and review checklist where the guide has them. Stratrix branded, and sent to your work email.
Questions
- What is an operating model?
- An operating model describes how an organization carries out its strategy: how it is structured, who makes which decisions, how work flows between units, what people are measured and rewarded on, and what capabilities it needs. It is broader than an org chart.
- What is a target operating model?
- A target operating model is the operating model an organization intends to have at a future date, written so the gap from the current model can be planned and closed in steps.
- What should an operating model template include?
- The strategic choices it serves, the decisions that matter most, structure, decision rights, the key processes, rewards and measures, people and capabilities, and the sequence of changes from today's model to the new one.
- What is the difference between an operating model and an organizational structure?
- The organizational structure is one part of the operating model: how units are grouped and who reports to whom. The operating model also covers decision rights, processes, rewards and people, which often matter more to how work actually gets done.
- What is the Star Model?
- Jay Galbraith's model of organization design. It groups design choices into five categories, strategy, structure, processes, rewards and people, and holds that they must be aligned with one another for an organization to be effective.
Sources
- Ballmer, S. (2013). One Microsoft: Company realigns to enable innovation at greater speed, efficiency (memo to employees, July 11, 2013). Microsoft News Center.
- Galbraith, J. R. (2014). The Star Model. Jay R. Galbraith.
Tools to try
- Business model canvas builderFramework: Business Model Canvas
- Change readiness checkFramework: Kotter's 8-Step Change Model
- SMART goal builderFramework: SMART Goals
- Ansoff move finderFramework: Ansoff Matrix
- Five Forces scorerFramework: Porter's Five Forces
- SWOT builderFramework: SWOT Analysis
More from Stratrix
“What is stopping a working pilot from reaching production?”
See the pack — $499 →Test a decision, free
Set a live decision against the companies that made it before you.
AcquisitionsThe Distance TestDivestituresThe Divestiture TestDiversificationThe Diversification TestMake or buyThe Make-or-Buy TestStratrix Team
Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.
$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →Weekly email
Stratonomics, every Tuesday
One data story every Tuesday: what happened, what it means, and the figures you can quote. Free.