Stratrix
Start here

Sixteen restaurant deals, and a range of five to one

On December 5, 2021, Jack in the Box agreed to buy Del Taco for $12.51 a share in cash, a premium of about 66 percent over Del Taco's closing price on the last trading day before the deal was signed 1. Before Del Taco's board said yes, its banker had to tell it whether the price was fair. One of the tests was a precedent transactions analysis: what had buyers paid for similar companies?

The banker found 16 restaurant acquisitions since 2010, from Apollo's purchase of CKE Restaurants to Restaurant Brands International's pending deal for Firehouse Subs. Measured as enterprise value against the target's last twelve months of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA), the prices ran from 5.3 times to 20.9 times, with a median of 10.7 1. Applied to Del Taco, that range implied a value of anywhere from $4.73 to $25.97 a share 1. Jack in the Box's offer worked out at 11.0 times, a whisker above the middle.

The banker said the obvious part out loud, in the proxy statement sent to shareholders: "No transaction utilized in the selected precedent transactions analysis is identical to the Company" 1. The less obvious part is what that range means for anyone building one. Sixteen deals did not produce a price. They produced a span wide enough to justify almost any price, and the work that decided the answer was choosing which deals belonged.

A precedent set is not a price tag. It is a list of what the most eager buyers paid, on their most confident day.

Start here

What a precedent price actually records

A precedent transaction is a completed (or agreed) acquisition of a company like the one you are valuing. You take what the buyer paid, usually as enterprise value (the price of the equity plus the debt taken on, less the cash acquired), divide it by a measure of the target's size, such as revenue or EBITDA, and apply that multiple to your own company. It is one of the standard ways to value a business: in Aswath Damodaran's survey of the field, relative valuation, pricing an asset against comparable ones, is one of four broad approaches, alongside discounted cash flow, asset-based valuation and option pricing 2.

Three things are baked into every precedent price, and none of them is the target's value on its own:

  • Control, synergy and overpayment. The buyer paid for the right to run the company, which is why deal prices sit above the share price minority investors trade at. Damodaran calls the premium in an acquisition "a composite value of control, synergy and overpayment" 5, and nobody can say from the price alone how much of each is in it. Del Taco's 66 percent premium is that composite, made visible 1.
  • The buyer's own plans. A buyer that expects to cut overlapping costs or sell more through its own channels can pay more than the business is worth to anyone else. The precedent price includes that buyer's synergies, which your buyer may not share.
  • The moment. Prices move with markets and with credit. In the Del Taco set, the six deals from 2010 to 2014 had a median of about 8 times EBITDA; the ten from 2016 on, about 11 1. Same industry, different decade.
Start here

Some precedents turned out to be mistakes

There is a fourth thing in a precedent price that nobody can see on the day: whether the buyer was right. In 2007 Rio Tinto bought Alcan for $38.1 billion in equity, roughly $44 billion including the debt it took on, near the top of the aluminum cycle 3. Anyone valuing an aluminum business the following year had a fresh, large, entirely real precedent to point to. On January 17, 2013, Rio Tinto announced a $10 billion to $11 billion write-down of its aluminum assets, mostly Alcan, and its chief executive stepped down the same day 4. By then, the cumulative write-downs on the deal had reached around $30 billion, close to 80 percent of the price 3.

Rio Tinto is not an outlier you can safely drop. In Stratrix's record of billion-dollar acquisitions whose endings are known, 79 of them, 23 clearly paid off, 35 were kept with results that were mixed or never clearly stated, and 21 went wrong: written down, sold off or never closed (the base rates). Any precedent set of big deals will contain some of the 21. The analysis treats them as evidence of value when they are, after the fact, evidence of overpayment. Damodaran puts the bias bluntly: because the average multiple paid is then used to justify the next price, "the values estimated using transactions multiples will generally be too high" 6.

In practice

Build a precedent set that tells you something

  1. Write the selection rules before you look at the multiplesDel Taco's banker set five: a controlling stake, announced between January 2010 and the opinion, limited-service restaurants, enterprise values of $100 million to $3 billion, and unit growth of 10 percent a year or less 1. Rules written first are a defense against keeping the deals that give the answer you hoped for.
  2. Find the deals and their numbersMerger proxy statements and tender offer documents filed with the SEC carry the bankers' fairness analyses, often with the full list of precedents and their multiples, as Del Taco's did 1. Company press releases give the price; the target's last annual report gives revenue and earnings for the twelve months before the announcement.
  3. Put every deal on the same footingUse enterprise value, not the equity headline, and the same earnings measure for every target, for the same period. A multiple of next year's EBITDA cannot sit in a column of last year's.
  4. Mark what happened nextFor each deal, note whether the buyer later wrote it down, sold it or kept it. A deal that ended in a write-down is still a real price, but it is not evidence that the business was worth that much.
  5. Report the range and the middle half, then explain your point in itShow the minimum, the 25th percentile, the median, the 75th percentile and the maximum. Then say which deals your company most resembles, and why, in a sentence. That sentence is the valuation.

The workbook on this page does the arithmetic: enter each deal's enterprise value and the target's earnings, mark whether to include it and what happened next, and it returns the range, the quartiles and the median, then applies them to your company's earnings and walks from enterprise value to a value per share. It opens with Del Taco's 16 precedents as the worked example.

Advanced

Where precedent analysis misleads

  • Taking the median as the answer. The median of a set chosen by someone with a view is that view, averaged. Lead with the range and your reasoning for the point within it.
  • Mixing buyers. A company that already owns similar brands can pay more than a private equity firm buying its first restaurant chain. If your likely buyer is one kind, weight the deals done by that kind, and say so.
  • Old prices in a new market. A deal from a decade ago reflects that decade's interest rates and stock market. Either keep the window short or show the multiples by period, as the Del Taco set reveals they should be.
  • Forgetting what the buyer was paying for. If the precedents were priced on synergies your buyer cannot get, their multiples overstate what your buyer should pay. The synergy case is a separate question; see M&A synergies.
  • Equity headline against enterprise multiple. A headline price may be equity value or enterprise value, and the two can differ by billions. Check which before dividing; enterprise value vs. equity value shows the bridge.

Used well, a precedent set answers a narrower question than people ask of it: not "what is this company worth?" but "what have buyers been willing to pay for companies like it, and what happened to them afterward?" The second half of that question is the half most analyses leave out.

Free editable template · XLSX

Precedent transactions workbook

A free, editable Excel workbook built from this guide: the template itself, how to fill it in, and the worked example and review checklist where the guide has them. Stratrix branded, and sent to your work email.

We'll email you a link to open it. Requesting it adds you to the Stratrix email list; unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.

Questions

What is a precedent transactions analysis?
A valuation method that looks at what buyers paid for comparable companies in past acquisitions. Each deal's price, usually as enterprise value, is divided by a measure of the target's size such as EBITDA, and the resulting range of multiples is applied to the company being valued.
Why are precedent transaction multiples higher than trading multiples?
Because a buyer in an acquisition pays for control and often for synergies it expects to capture. Listed shares trade as minority stakes without either, so their multiples are usually lower. The gap is the premium: Del Taco's buyer paid about 66 percent over its recent share price.
How many precedent transactions should you use?
Enough to show a range, chosen by rules written before you look at the multiples. Del Taco's banker used 16 restaurant deals from 2010 to 2021. More deals do not help if they are less comparable; fewer, closer deals with a clear rationale are more useful.
What are the limits of precedent transactions?
No two deals are identical, prices reflect the market and credit conditions of their time, and they include each buyer's own synergies. Some precedents also turned out to be overpayments: Rio Tinto wrote off close to 80 percent of what it paid for Alcan.
Where do you find precedent transaction data?
Merger proxy statements and tender offer documents filed with the SEC often summarize the bankers' fairness analyses, including the precedent deals and their multiples. Press releases give prices, and targets' annual reports give their revenue and earnings.

Sources

  1. Del Taco Restaurants, Inc. (2022). Definitive proxy statement (Schedule 14A) for the merger with Jack in the Box Inc., filed January 28, 2022. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
  2. Damodaran, A. (2006). Valuation Approaches and Metrics: A Survey of the Theory and Evidence. Stern School of Business, New York University.
  3. Stratrix (2026). Rio Tinto and the commodity cycle (Decision Record). Stratrix.
  4. Rio Tinto plc (2013). Rio Tinto impairments and management changes, media release of January 17, 2013 (exhibit 99.1 to Form 6-K). US Securities and Exchange Commission.
  5. Damodaran, A. (2005). The Value of Control: Implications for Control Premia, Minority Discounts and Voting Share Differentials. Stern School of Business, New York University.
  6. Damodaran, A. (2002). Investment Valuation, 2nd edition, chapter 25: Acquisitions and Takeovers. John Wiley & Sons.

For information and strategic analysis only, not investment advice. Stratrix does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security.

Tools to try

More from Stratrix

Strategy Packs
The Road Not Taken

“What did the decision you did not take actually cost?”

One decision per pack: the framework, a working model, the sourced cases and the board material.

See the pack — $499 →

Stratrix Team

Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.

$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →

Weekly email

Stratonomics, every Tuesday

One data story every Tuesday: what happened, what it means, and the figures you can quote. Free.

We'll email you a link to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy.