Stellantis beat its synergy target by two-thirds. Then the bill arrived.
When Peugeot's parent and Fiat Chrysler merged to form Stellantis in January 2021, the promise was the kind boards love: about €5 billion a year in cost savings 1. Platforms would be shared, purchasing combined, overlapping offices folded together.
By the company's own account, it delivered. For 2023, Stellantis reported €8.4 billion of net cash synergies, "exceeding the €5 billion annual steady state target established at the time of the merger," and added that it had done so "more than two years earlier than planned" 2. On the scorecard every merger keeps, this was a triumph.
The next year, net revenues fell 17 percent, to €156.9 billion 3. On December 1, 2024, Carlos Tavares, who had run Stellantis since the merger, resigned as chief executive 3. The savings were real. They simply were not the number the deal turned on.
A synergy target tells you whether a buyer kept its promise. It does not tell you whether the promise was worth making.
What most people believe about synergies
A synergy is the value two companies create together that neither would create alone: costs that disappear when two head offices become one, or revenue that appears when one company's products reach the other's customers. The conventional wisdom splits them into two kinds. Cost synergies are counted as the safe ones, because a buyer controls them: close the duplicate plant, merge the payroll. Revenue synergies are counted as the risky ones, because they depend on customers doing something new.
The best-known evidence seems to agree. Reporting on a McKinsey study of 160 mergers, CFO magazine put it this way: "70 percent of mergers fall short when it comes to achieving their targets for revenue synergies, while 40 percent lead to cost-synergy disappointments" 7. Read the second half again: even the safe kind disappointed in two deals out of five. But the lesson most people took was the first half.
So the advice writes itself: build the case on costs, treat revenue as upside, and track the savings until they are banked. Stellantis followed it to the letter.
In 66 deals, the safe kind failed just as often
Stratrix keeps a record of 78 acquisitions whose endings are known, from Samsung buying Korea Semiconductor in 1974 to Walmart buying Vizio in 2024. For 66 of them, the reporting says what the deal case counted on. Fifteen were justified mainly by cost savings; five of those went wrong, meaning sold off, unwound or written down. Fifty-one were justified mainly by revenue and growth; seventeen went wrong. One in three, either way.
The list of cost deals that went wrong is not a list of buyers who failed to cut. Kraft and Heinz announced "an estimated $1.5 billion in annual cost savings implemented by the end of 2017" 5; in February 2019 the combined company announced $15.4 billion of impairment losses on goodwill and on brands including Kraft and Oscar Mayer 6, the charge that became the emblem of the deal. HP set out to cut $2.5 billion from the combined operations with Compaq, and the goal "was exceeded by more than $1 billion" 4; HP later split itself back in two. The savings arrived in each case. The question each deal faced was somewhere else.
And some of the growth deals that worked said so in exactly those words. Looking back a decade after BlackRock bought Barclays Global Investors, one of the people involved put it to Barron's: "It was successful because it wasn't a cost play. It was adding things that we could never have built on our own" 8. Bayer described its purchase of Monsanto in almost the same terms, as "primarily about driving innovation, growth and investment, rather than cost-cutting considerations" 9. BlackRock's deal paid off; Bayer's went wrong. Same pitch, opposite endings.
Sixty-six deals is not a law of nature, and the split between cost and revenue is the reporters' and the companies' own. But the pattern is hard to miss: the kind of synergy a deal promised did not separate the winners from the losers. Something else did.
The synergy number is the price, not the prize
Mark Sirower has spent a career on the arithmetic that explains why. A premium is paid on the day the deal closes; the synergy is what has to arrive afterward to earn it back. Sirower and his co-author describe a model that, for any deal "requiring a significant premium over market," works out the "combinations of cost reductions and revenue enhancements that would justify that premium" 10. The premium comes first. The synergy case is the list of things that must be true to pay for it.
The arithmetic is short. A synergy that arrives every year is worth roughly its yearly amount divided by the cost of capital, so each dollar of premium needs about eight cents a year of permanent synergy at an 8 percent cost of capital, and more if the savings take years to build or cost money to achieve. Take a fictional buyer paying a $2 billion premium, spending $400 million to integrate, with an 8 percent cost of capital: it needs about $192 million a year of synergy, forever, just to stand still ($2.4 billion times 8 percent). Every dollar beyond that is the actual return on the deal.
Seen that way, the synergy target is not upside. It is the bill the buyer has already paid, announced as if it were the reward. Hitting it means breaking even on the premium. It says nothing about what else the combination did to the business, which is where the deals in the record went wrong: customers who left, products that stalled, a business distracted for three years while two head offices became one.
Five questions for the synergy case
- What is the break-even synergy?Premium plus the cost to integrate, times the cost of capital, is the yearly synergy needed just to pay for the deal. Put that number in the first paragraph of the case, beside the synergy target. If the target is barely above it, the deal is a bet on execution with no margin.
- Which synergies need ownership?For each line of the synergy case, ask whether a contract, a joint venture or a hire would get it without buying the company. Savings you could get another way do not justify a premium. BlackRock's test was the right one: what could we never have built on our own?
- What could the combination cost?List the revenue at risk: customers who buy from both companies and will consolidate, customers who chose the target because it was not the buyer, products that lose their team. Put a number on it and subtract it from the synergy case. No synergy scorecard counts this line, which is why it needs to be written down before the deal.
- When does each synergy arrive, and what does it cost to get?Write the phase-in by year and the cost to achieve. A synergy that arrives in year four is worth far less than the same synergy in year one, and the premium was paid on day one.
- Who owns each line, and what is the measure after close?Give every synergy an owner and a measure that reaches the accounts, not a percentage of initiatives completed. Then add a second measure the scorecard usually leaves out: revenue and customers in the combined business against a baseline.
Cost synergies vs. revenue synergies, side by side
| Cost synergies | Revenue synergies | |
|---|---|---|
| Where they come from | Duplicate overhead, plants, systems, purchasing power | Cross-selling, new markets, combined products, pricing |
| Who controls them | Mostly the buyer | Mostly customers |
| How they are usually tracked | Run-rate savings against the target | Often not at all, or as pipeline |
| What the tracking misses | Revenue lost while costs were cut | Whether customers wanted the combination |
| The question to ask | Could we get this without buying? | Why would customers buy more from us together? |
Neither column is safe. A cost case can be delivered in full while the business it was cutting shrinks around it; a revenue case can be right about the market and wrong about the customers. The discipline is the same for both: price the premium, name what only ownership delivers, and count what the combination costs.
After close: keep two scorecards
Integration teams report synergies because synergies are what they were asked to deliver. Keep that scorecard, and keep a second one beside it for the business the deal was meant to improve: revenue by customer group against the year before the deal, retention of the target's top customers and top people, and the market share of each brand. Review the two together, at the same meeting.
- The synergy scorecard: savings and revenue gains reaching the accounts, by line, against plan, with owners.
- The business scorecard: revenue, customers and share in the combined business, against a baseline set before close.
- The question for the board each quarter: are we on track to earn back the premium, net of what the combination has cost? A yes on the first scorecard and a no on the second is the Stellantis pattern, and the time to see it is year one, not year four.
The Integration Strategy Pack turns this into arithmetic for a live deal: the break-even synergy, the share of the promise that can be missed before the deal stops paying, and the year the promise arrives at the current pace, with the integrations that went each way.
Questions
- What are synergies in M&A?
- Synergies are the extra value two companies create together that neither would create alone. Cost synergies come from removing duplication, such as two head offices or overlapping plants. Revenue synergies come from selling more together, such as cross-selling one company's products to the other's customers.
- What is the difference between cost synergies and revenue synergies?
- Cost synergies reduce what the combined company spends and are mostly in the buyer's control. Revenue synergies increase what it sells and depend on customers. Cost synergies are usually seen as more reliable, but a deal can deliver its cost savings in full and still fail if the combined business loses revenue.
- How do you calculate break-even synergies?
- Add the acquisition premium and the one-time cost to integrate, then multiply by the cost of capital. The result is roughly the yearly synergy, sustained indefinitely, needed just to pay for the premium. Synergies that take years to arrive need to be larger.
- Do mergers usually achieve their synergies?
- Many deliver the savings they announce; Stellantis reported €8.4 billion against a €5 billion target. Delivering the target and creating value are different tests, though. In Stratrix's record of acquisitions, deals justified by cost savings went wrong about as often as deals justified by growth: roughly one in three.
- What should a synergy case include?
- The break-even synergy, each synergy line with the reason it requires ownership, the revenue the combination could lose, the year each synergy arrives and its cost to achieve, and an owner and measure for each line after close.
Sources
- CNBC (2021). Fiat Chrysler and PSA Groupe shareholders approve merger. CNBC, January 4, 2021.
- Stellantis N.V. (2024). Annual report on Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2023. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- Stellantis N.V. (2025). Annual report on Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2024. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- LaPlante, A. (2007). Compaq and HP: Ultimately, the Urge to Merge Was Right. Stanford Graduate School of Business, Insights (June 1, 2007).
- H. J. Heinz Holding Corporation and Kraft Foods Group (2015). Merger announcement, exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- The Kraft Heinz Company (2019). Annual report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 29, 2018. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- Frieswick, K. (2005). Fool's Gold (reporting a McKinsey & Company study of 160 mergers). CFO, February 1, 2005.
- Barron's (2019). BlackRock's Barclays Deal, 10 Years Later. Barron's.
- Bayer AG and Monsanto Company (2016). Merger announcement materials, exhibit 99 to Form 8-K. US Securities and Exchange Commission.
- Sirower, M. L. and Sahni, S. (2006). Avoiding the "Synergy Trap". Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 18(3), 83–95.
For information and strategic analysis only, not investment advice. Stratrix does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security.
Tools to try
- Ansoff move finderFramework: Ansoff Matrix
- Five Forces scorerFramework: Porter's Five Forces
- SWOT builderFramework: SWOT Analysis
- Business model canvas builderFramework: Business Model Canvas
- Change readiness checkFramework: Kotter's 8-Step Change Model
- SMART goal builderFramework: SMART Goals
More from Stratrix
“You told the market what the deal would deliver; who is on the hook, and by when?”
See the pack — $499 →Test a decision, free
Set a live decision against the companies that made it before you.
AcquisitionsThe Distance TestDivestituresThe Divestiture TestDiversificationThe Diversification TestMake or buyThe Make-or-Buy TestStratrix Team
Every Casebook, three Strategy Packs a seat each year and Ask Stratrix, for teams that face these decisions all year.
$1,999 a year · $499 a seatWhat is included →Strategic Decisions
The big calls companies keep facing, told through the 819 companies on record that made them.
24 decisionsFind your decision →New analyses, by email
The defining moves in business, and what they teach, as they publish.