Skill-Will Matrix
Also known as: Skill Will Matrix, Competence-Motivation Matrix
A 2x2 matrix that helps managers choose the right management approach based on an employee's skill level and willingness/motivation for a given task.
Quick Reference
Memory Aid
High Skill + High Will = Delegate. Low Skill + High Will = Guide. High Skill + Low Will = Excite. Low both = Direct.
TL;DR
Map each person's skill and motivation for each task on a 2x2 grid. Guide enthusiastic beginners, delegate to capable and motivated performers, direct those lacking both, and excite skilled but unmotivated individuals. Reassess regularly.
What Is Skill-Will Matrix?
Assess each person's skill and motivation for a task, then choose the right approach: Guide (low skill, high will), Delegate (high skill, high will), Direct (low skill, low will), or Excite (high skill, low will).
The role of the manager is not to do the work themselves but to create the conditions in which others can do their best work. That starts with understanding where each person is.
— Max Landsberg, The Tao of Coaching
The Skill-Will Matrix is a simple diagnostic tool that helps managers match their approach to each employee's readiness. By plotting an employee's skill (competence for the task) against their will (motivation and confidence), managers can choose from four approaches: Guide those who are eager but inexperienced, Delegate to competent and motivated performers, Direct those who lack both skill and motivation, and Excite those who have the skill but have lost motivation.
Skill-Will Matrix
Four management approaches based on skill and motivation levels
Guide
Train and coach
Delegate
Empower and trust
Direct
Structure and monitor
Excite
Motivate and challenge
Origin & Context
Introduced in Landsberg's book 'The Tao of Coaching' as a practical diagnostic tool for managers.
Core Components
Guide (High Will, Low Skill)
The person is enthusiastic but lacks capability. Invest in training and coaching.
Example
A new graduate is eager to lead projects but needs skill development. Provide structured training with mentoring.
Delegate (High Will, High Skill)
The person is capable and motivated. Give autonomy and challenging assignments.
Example
A senior engineer is passionate and expert. Give full ownership of a critical initiative with minimal oversight.
Direct (Low Will, Low Skill)
The person lacks both motivation and capability. Provide clear direction and close monitoring.
Example
An underperforming employee needs clear expectations, structured tasks, and regular check-ins.
Excite (Low Will, High Skill)
The person is capable but unmotivated. Re-engage through recognition, new challenges, or understanding root causes.
Example
A talented but bored developer is given a challenging innovation project and public recognition for past contributions.
Did You Know?
The Skill-Will Matrix was popularized through McKinsey & Company's internal coaching practices before Max Landsberg published it in 'The Tao of Coaching' in 1996. It became one of the most widely used quick-diagnostic tools in management consulting because it can be applied in under 15 minutes per employee.
When to Use Skill-Will Matrix
Quick management diagnostic
Problem it solves: Managers use the same approach with everyone regardless of readiness.
Real-World Application
A team lead maps all 8 team members on the matrix in 30 minutes and immediately adjusts her approach for each.
Addressing performance issues
Problem it solves: Unclear whether a performance problem is a skill issue or a motivation issue.
Real-World Application
A manager realizes a 'poor performer' actually has high skill but low will due to lack of recognition, shifting the intervention from training to engagement.
Delegation planning
Problem it solves: Leaders struggle to know what to delegate and to whom.
Real-World Application
A director uses the matrix to identify who can take on more responsibility (Delegate quadrant) and who needs support first.
Skill and will are task-specific. Someone might be high-skill/high-will for coding but low-skill/high-will for presenting. Always assess per task.
How to Apply Skill-Will Matrix: Step by Step
Before You Start
- →Knowledge of each team member's capabilities
- →Understanding of motivation factors
- →Specific tasks or responsibilities to assess
Identify the task or responsibility
Be specific about what task or role aspect you are assessing.
Tips
- ✓Break broad roles into specific tasks for more accurate assessment
Common Mistakes
- ✗Assessing the whole person rather than specific tasks
Assess skill level
Evaluate the person's current competence for this specific task.
Tips
- ✓Use evidence: past performance, certifications, demonstrated ability
Common Mistakes
- ✗Conflating potential with current skill
Assess will level
Evaluate the person's motivation, confidence, and enthusiasm for this task.
Tips
- ✓Have a conversation — ask about their interest and confidence
- ✓Look for behavioral signals
Common Mistakes
- ✗Assuming will based on personality rather than observing task-specific motivation
Choose and apply the right approach
Based on the quadrant, select Guide, Delegate, Direct, or Excite and act accordingly.
Tips
- ✓Communicate your approach openly
- ✓Reassess regularly as skill and will change
Common Mistakes
- ✗Sticking with one approach after skill or will has shifted
Value & Outcomes
Primary Benefit
Quickly diagnoses the right management approach for each person and task.
Additional Benefits
- ✓Prevents over-managing skilled employees
- ✓Identifies the real root cause of performance issues
- ✓Provides a simple, shareable management language
What You'll Learn
- →How to differentiate skill problems from motivation problems
- →How to adapt your management style to individual needs
- →How to delegate more effectively
Typical Outcomes
Best Practices
📋 Preparation
- •List specific tasks or responsibilities for each team member before mapping
🚀 Execution
- •Assess per task, not per person
- •Update assessments regularly as people develop
- •Use the matrix as a conversation starter, not a permanent label
🔄 Follow-Up
- •Track movement across quadrants over time
- •Aim to move everyone toward the Delegate quadrant
💎 Pro Tips
- •Use this in tandem with one-on-ones: 'For this task, where do you feel you are on skill and motivation?'
- •If someone is in the Direct quadrant for multiple tasks, it may be a role-fit issue, not a coaching issue
Don't confuse low will with laziness. It often signals burnout, unclear expectations, personal issues, or feeling undervalued. Investigate before labeling.
Spotify's Squad Management
Spotify's engineering managers use a variation of the Skill-Will Matrix to determine how to manage different squad members on different projects. A developer might be in the 'Delegate' quadrant for backend development but in the 'Guide' quadrant for a new machine learning initiative — leading managers to provide differentiated support rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.
Limitations & Pitfalls
Oversimplifies the complexity of motivation and capability
Mitigation: Use as a quick diagnostic, supplement with deeper tools like Situational Leadership
Skill and will assessments can be subjective
Mitigation: Use evidence-based assessment and include the employee's self-assessment
Apply Skill-Will Matrix with Stratrix
Turn this framework into a professional strategy deck in under a minute. Stratrix applies Skill-Will Matrix automatically to your business context.
Try Stratrix Free